← Back to blog

Costs Orders in the Fair Work Commission: When They Happen

November 11, 2026
Costs Orders in the Fair Work Commission: When They Happen

In the Fair Work Commission (FWC), each party normally pays its own costs, win or lose. A costs order, where one side is told to pay some of the other's legal costs, is a rare exception. It is reserved for specific situations: claims or responses made vexatiously or without reasonable cause, and, in unfair dismissal matters, unreasonable conduct that caused the other side to spend money. This guide explains where that line sits, how a costs application works, and how to run your matter so you stay well clear of one.

Terminationhelp
Navigate Fair Work claims with clarity
Terminationhelp guides users through Australian Fair Work procedures, helps generate forms, and explains each stage of unfair dismissal proceedings.
Visit

TL;DR

  • The default rule is that each party bears its own costs, whatever the outcome. Winning does not mean the other side pays your legal fees.
  • The FWC can order costs only in limited circumstances, such as a vexatious application or response, no reasonable prospects, or an unreasonable act or omission in an unfair dismissal matter.
  • A costs application must be made on Form F6 within 14 days after the Commission decides the matter or it is discontinued.
  • Costs orders can also be made against a lawyer or paid agent, not just the party.
  • Careful, well-organised preparation and a genuine response to settlement offers are the best protection for employees and employers alike.

Table of Contents

The general rule: you pay your own way

The starting point is simple. The Fair Work Commission explains that parties generally pay their own costs, and that the Commission has discretion to order one party to pay another's costs only in specific, limited circumstances. Winning an unfair dismissal case does not change that default.

Legal Aid NSW describes the Commission as a no-costs jurisdiction, which means costs orders are exceptions rather than the norm. Commentary in the legal profession notes the policy behind this: each side bearing its own costs is intended to protect employees from financial risk and discourage protracted, inefficient litigation.

For an employee, that is good news in both directions. If you lose, you are not normally exposed to your employer's legal bill. If you win, you should not expect to be reimbursed for yours, so it pays to plan what you will spend before you start.

What "costs" actually means for you

When people talk about costs in unfair dismissal, they usually mean one of two things.

  1. Your own expenses of running the case. These include any legal fees you choose to pay, plus expenses such as fees for subpoenas, witnesses, and copies of records or expert reports. Legal Aid NSW notes that these are generally borne by the party who incurs them.
  2. A costs order. This is a formal order by the Commission that one party pay some or all of the other party's costs. It is the subject of the rest of this article.

The filing fee for an unfair dismissal application is a third category: a fixed fee paid to lodge, not a costs order. We break down what lodging costs in our guide to the unfair dismissal filing fee.

A useful budgeting fact for employees: the remedy is limited. If you are not seeking reinstatement, the total remedy for a successful claim is no more than six months' pay, and our article on unfair dismissal remedies and the compensation cap explains how the cap works. Because the ceiling is known, spending heavily on lawyers can quickly outweigh what you might recover, and costs orders will not top that up.

When the Commission can order costs

The FWC's costs page sets out two broad tests. The Commission may order costs if it is satisfied that:

  • an application was made, or a response to an application was made, vexatiously or without reasonable cause; or
  • the application or response had no reasonable prospect of success.

In unfair dismissal matters there is an additional pathway. Costs may also be awarded where an unreasonable act or omission caused the other party to incur costs. The FWC gives examples: failing to discontinue the matter, or failing to agree to settlement terms, when doing so was unreasonable.

Two features of these tests matter in practice.

The Commission works in two steps. It first asks whether it has power to make an order at all, meaning one of the circumstances above is made out. Only then does it ask whether, in its discretion, an order should actually be made. Even a party who clears the first hurdle can fail at the second.

The bar is high. In Daniel King v Patrick Projects Pty Ltd [2020] FWC 2758, the Commission stressed that a decision to award costs should be reached with extreme caution and is reserved for cases that are manifestly untenable or groundless. An employment law handbook bulletin puts it more bluntly: recovering costs in FWC proceedings is a high bar to jump.

Vexatious, no reasonable cause, no reasonable prospects

These concepts overlap. A claim made to harass or embarrass the other side, or made with no real basis, is the classic example. A claim that is merely weak or ends up unsuccessful is not enough. Plenty of genuine claims lose, and losing alone is not a ground for costs.

Unreasonable acts or omissions

This limb is the one employees and small businesses are most likely to encounter, because it is about conduct during the case rather than the merits at the start. In a 2023 Commission decision on a costs application under s 400A, an employer sought 75% of its legal fees after incurring costs in an application to dismiss a claim, in circumstances where the applicant had indicated he would discontinue. The point for readers is the pattern: if you say you will withdraw, or a settlement is on the table, and you then delay, the other side can warn you that further costs will be claimed. Always read the outcome of a decision itself before relying on it, because each costs result depends on its facts.

Unreasonable acts or omissions

Costs orders against lawyers and paid agents

The power is not limited to the parties. The Commission may also order costs against legal representatives, meaning a lawyer or paid agent. Practically, this is a reminder to anyone who represents others: bringing a hopeless case, or conducting one unreasonably, carries personal risk. It is also a reason for a person who engages representation to expect the representative to give frank advice on prospects.

How to apply for a costs order

If you think the other side's conduct falls within the rules, the process is strict on timing.

  1. Complete Form F6. The FWC's Form F6 page says this is the form used to apply for payment of costs.
  2. Lodge within 14 days. The application must be lodged within 14 days after the Commission issues its decision, or after the matter is discontinued, as the FWC's costs guidance explains. Treat that deadline as firm. It is far shorter than most people expect.
  3. Set out your grounds. Identify which circumstance applies (for example, vexatious conduct, no reasonable prospects, or an unreasonable refusal of a settlement offer) and attach the evidence: correspondence, offers, and dates.
  4. Expect the two-step test. The Commission will decide whether it has power, then whether to exercise discretion.

If an application is made against you, respond on the merits and on discretion. Show what you did, when, and why it was reasonable.

Courts are different

Costs rules in the Federal Circuit and Family Court and the Federal Court are not the same as the Commission's. A court generally cannot order costs in a Fair Work Act matter unless one of the listed circumstances applies. Commentary on section 570 confirms that it prevents a court from ordering costs unless a specified circumstance is met. Under the FWC's guidance on the role of the court in unfair dismissal cases (applying from 1 July 2023), a court may order costs if a party:

  • started proceedings vexatiously or without reasonable cause;
  • caused costs through an unreasonable act or omission; or
  • unreasonably refused to participate in a related Commission matter.

The practical lesson is that engaging properly with the Commission process, including conciliation, is also protective if the matter ever reaches a court.

A note on AI-assisted claims

Lawyers have started writing about a rise in poorly founded claims prepared with generic AI tools. One firm's insight describes recent Commission decisions as highlighting a growing problem of AI-assisted unmeritorious claims and a practical response through costs orders. The takeaway for applicants is not that preparation help is risky. It is that whatever you use must be grounded in the actual law and your actual facts. A claim built on generic text that misstates eligibility, or that ignores a deadline, serves nobody.

How employees can stay clear of a costs order

Most genuine applicants never face a costs application. These habits keep it that way.

  • Check eligibility first. Confirm you meet the minimum employment period and income threshold, are covered by the system, and are within time. Our unfair dismissal eligibility guide walks through each check.
  • Lodge on time. The deadline is 21 days from the day your dismissal took effect. See how to file an unfair dismissal claim within 21 days and the Form F2 steps.
  • Say what happened, accurately. Good unfair dismissal particulars are specific, consistent and supported by documents.
  • Know the process. The Commission process step by step shows where conciliation, directions and hearings fit.
  • Respond to settlement offers reasonably. You are free to say no, but think through why, and record your reasons. Unreasonably refusing terms is exactly what the unreasonable-conduct limb looks at.
  • Be willing to discontinue if you learn something that sinks your claim, and do it promptly.
  • Mitigate your loss. Looking for work and keeping records is part of a credible claim. See our guide on mitigation of loss.

How small businesses can stay clear of one

Employers are exposed to the same two limbs. A response filed without a real basis, or a refusal to engage with reasonable settlement terms, can attract a costs application.

  • Take the claim seriously from day one and respond within the time set.
  • Gather the dismissal paperwork, performance records and warnings early. Procedural fairness is often the point on which these cases turn.
  • Raise genuine jurisdictional objections (for example, eligibility or time) clearly and early, with evidence.
  • Consider settlement offers on their merits. If you reject one, be able to explain why it was reasonable.
  • Understand how the Commission reads authorities. Our guide to reading unfair dismissal case law helps you test your position against decided cases.

If you are unsure whether a costs order is realistic in your situation, speak to an employment lawyer, your union or a community legal centre. Costs outcomes depend heavily on individual facts.

Quick reference

QuestionShort answer
Who pays costs by default?Each party pays its own
Does winning mean costs are paid?No
Main grounds for a costs orderVexatious or no reasonable cause; no reasonable prospects; unreasonable act or omission (unfair dismissal)
Can a lawyer or agent be ordered to pay?Yes
Form and deadlineForm F6, within 14 days after the decision or discontinuance
How hard is it to succeed?A high bar, used with caution

Our perspective

We built Terminationhelp because most costs problems start long before a hearing. They start with a claim lodged late, forms completed from guesswork, or evidence scattered across emails and phones.

The Commission's own rule is that each side pays its own way and that costs orders are exceptional. That is reassuring, but it also means the quality of your preparation is the thing you control. A claim that is eligible, on time, and clearly set out is the opposite of a claim made without reasonable cause.

That is why our platform is dedicated to Australian Fair Work claims. It is designed around Australian legislation, Fair Work Commission rules and relevant case law, and it walks you through eligibility checks, evidence organisation, timelines and the forms you need at each stage. You can then file yourself, or bring the structured packet to a lawyer, union or community legal centre, which can save time and cost.

We do not predict outcomes or give legal advice. We help you prepare properly so that your decisions, including whether to settle, are made with the facts in front of you.

Nicolas

Prepare your matter properly

If you are facing a dismissal, or you are a small business responding to a claim, good preparation is the most practical protection against wasted cost. Our preparation support combines step-by-step guidance, eligibility checks, evidence organisation, document upload and generation of the Fair Work forms you need, grounded in Australian law and Commission procedure.

Terminationhelp

You can see how it works on our preparation support page. Lawyers, unions and businesses can also use it to prepare client or member matters.

FAQ

Usually not. The Commission's default rule is that each party pays its own costs. An order against you is possible only in limited circumstances, such as a vexatious claim, no reasonable prospects, or unreasonable conduct that caused the other side to spend money.

If I win, will my employer pay my lawyer?

Not automatically. Winning does not trigger a costs order. Any remedy you receive, such as compensation or reinstatement, is separate from legal costs, and your own expenses generally stay with you.

How long do I have to apply for costs?

You must lodge Form F6 within 14 days after the Commission decides the matter or it is discontinued, according to the FWC's Form F6 page. Because the window is short, decide early whether you intend to apply and gather your evidence of the other side's conduct.

Can a lawyer or paid agent be ordered to pay costs?

Yes. The Commission may order costs against legal representatives as well as parties. It is an exceptional step, but it is one reason representatives should give honest advice about a case's prospects.

Does refusing a settlement offer lead to a costs order?

Not by itself. In unfair dismissal matters, though, the Commission can consider whether failing to agree to settlement terms was an unreasonable act or omission that caused costs. Consider each offer carefully and keep a record of your reasons.

Sources

Article produced using AI. This is not legal advice.